<< November, 2008 >>
SMTWTFS
1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30
Search Blog

Paying Bills
Recent Entries
Recent Comments
Re: SysCon - Irony in Advertising (by matthewreinbold at 2/17 7:32 PM)
Re: New Words: Web Worker Daily (by Anne Z. at 2/10 8:30 AM)
Re: New Words: Web Worker Daily (by Jason Alba at 2/10 6:59 AM)
Re: New Words: Web Worker Daily (by Michael Moncur at 2/10 6:18 AM)
Re: 2006: Tying Up Odds 'n Ends (by matthewreinbold at 1/05 11:06 PM)
Re: 2006: Tying Up Odds 'n Ends (by Jason Alba at 1/05 7:22 PM)
Re: 2006: Tying Up Odds 'n Ends (by Gilbert Lee at 1/04 2:21 AM)
Re: Returns Week: Build Your Own Geek Box (by Laura Moncur at 1/03 1:15 AM)
Re: JSEclipse Preview Available! (by matthewreinbold at 12/21 2:21 PM)
Re: JSEclipse Preview Available! (by scott at 12/20 11:51 PM)
About
Matthew Reinbold is the writer behind the BloomBurst blog. BloomBurst is written by Matthew Reinbold. He currently lives in Salt Lake, Utah and has been a web designer, site developer, and usability engineer since 1999.

Matthew graduated from the South Dakota School of Mines and Technology (SDSM&T) in 2000 with a bachelors degree in computer engineering. In 2003 he received his MBA from the University of Utah with an emphasis on entrepreneurship and emerging technology business.

More development perspective can be found on the Salt Lake ColdFusion User Group website, a group that Matthew has been president of since April, 2005. He also writes about communities and collaborative culture on mutednoise.com. He can be contacted via the form on Vox Pop Design, the web design firm where he serves as Creative Principal. Finally, he's LinkedIn.

Categories
Archives
Photo Albums
Images (1)
RSS

Powered by
BlogCFM v1.14

Web Design by
Vox Pop Design

24 July 2006
Utah's Dolphins vs. the Silicon Valley Sharks
Adobe Community Summit Discussions, Vol 3

While at last week’s Adobe Community summit I had the privilege of pinging a bunch of really intelligent thinkers and software community leaders. Given that we were being wined and dined in the heart of Silicon Valley it was inevitable that the conversation returned to observations of the area.

In Vol. 2 discussion recap I mentioned that we can’t abstract away the importance of personal presence. Current geographical zones that dominate –whether economically, technically, or culturally - will continue to dominate. As Dan Dodge, a member of Microsoft’s Emerging Business Team says, “success attracts more success”. Silicon Valley has this in spades. We can’t deny that any software development denizen envies the wealth of opportunities and the energy of the community (if not the property values). How do we create the same for Utah? How do we create the ‘Info Interior’?

There are several things that are necessary for a geographical cluster to take root. The first is an International Airport that provides a conduit for talent and talking heads – check. There needs to be numerous schools of higher learning churning out cheap entry level cubical fodder ambitious and energetic graduates – while the U of U, BYU, UVSC, etc. may not be the level of Berkley I think its safe to say that this is a check. Of course we must not forget about money. Given the efforts of organization like MountainWest Capital Network and the Funding Utah angels things are looking up in that area. Check.

However, there is a glaring difference. As Dan says:

Silicon Valley has the highest concentration of ‘Type A’ personalities I have ever seen in my life. They compete at everything...all the time. This competitive atmosphere pushes you beyond what you thought was possible. It inspires innovative thinking that you didn't think you were capable of. I call it a ‘force field’ of competitive energy. It is amazing, invigorating, stimulating, and rewarding.”

I’m guessing it’s not a ‘force field’ of competitive energy that is responsible for this summer’s inversion. Numerous examples of the stereotypical Valley entrepreneur exist: the young, unmarried, 80-hour a week work-a-holic who sets out to remake the world (and a lot of money along the way). Work is the priority; things like family, travel, and even spirituality are placed on the back burner. We call safely call these individuals sharks; they've got a bloodlust to win bordering on animal instinct.

Contrast this with the stereotypical image of a newly graduated BYU entrepreneur. They are already married, might have children, and place church and family firmly at the top of the priority heap. They desire to make a comfortable living as long as it remains between 9-5. For comparison I'll call these highly intelligent, squeaky-clean individuals dolphins.

One doesn’t have to catch many National Geographic specials to know that if a dolphin tries to swim with the sharks a commercial is cut to quickly. A dolphin’s set of Sea World tricks are a poor foil for the tenacity of a shark’s appetite. Of course, there is nothing wrong with dolphins swimming with other dolphins to some success: examples include the recently emergent Mormon cinema scene to Ancestry and MyFamily .com’s.

The trick to a vibrant and success-attracting Info Interior, however, is to be able to swim with the sharks and win. I think most people in this area don’t want to abandon our family friendliness and work-life balance just to have a little more green after an 80-hour week. So how do we compete?

Posted by matthewreinbold at 8:23 PM | Link | 3 comments
Subscription Options

You are not logged in, so your subscription status for this entry is unknown. You can login or register here.

Re: Utah's Dolphins vs. the Silicon Valley Sharks
That's a fascinating observation. Ideally, I'd like to think that you can have a life and still be competitive, but I think you're right as long as you are comparing apples to apples. It isn't just the time worked, but if the quality is the same, those driven to work long hours to pull off great things will go further than those who spend less time doing the same.
Posted by Jacob on July 25, 2006 at 11:19 AM

Re: Utah's Dolphins vs. the Silicon Valley Sharks
You probably already saw this Paul Graham essay about how to create Silicon Valley, but if not, maybe it's worth reading: http://www.paulgraham.com/siliconvalley.html

Also, Guy Kawasaki has an interesting post on his blog about the topic:
http://blog.guykawasaki.com/2006/06/how_to_kick_sil.html

For what it's worth, bottlenose dolphins have been known to gang up on, attack and successfully drive off an encroaching shark.

Finally, allow me to suggest a different, very powerful sea mammal to imitate: the killer whale. They've been known to rip apart Great Whites and dine on their livers.
Posted by albert on July 25, 2006 at 8:40 PM

Re: Utah's Dolphins vs. the Silicon Valley Sharks
Thanks for the kind words Jacob. It's a wonder what analogies one thinks up while waiting in an airport. You do have a point: I'm dealing with some pretty stock sterotypes here. There is nothing stopping someone in Utah from being very aggressive and vice versa.

And thanks for the links albert - I know I've been stumbling over great articles on this very subject for awhile now but Dan's was the last one in my bookmark list and, therefore, was the one that ended up getting used. I'll definately check those out to make sure I haven't missed anything.

About the killer whale: I'm not sure that's a desirable archtype for Utah's development community either. The contrast I was trying to draw with the shark reference was the A-type personality; the bloodlust to survive at all costs. Killer whales, with the ripping and the dining, smacks of this same mentality. The goal is to succeed with what we are and not try and become something we're not.

I DO like your reference to what dolphins can do en masse. Building communities that support, strengthen, and even defend one another might be a strategy. However, any great technology group model (everything for Xerox PARC to BarCamp) that I can think of has originated... well, near the pacific. Not only are there sharks but they group too. :)
Posted by matthewreinbold on July 25, 2006 at 11:19 PM

Commenting has been disabled for this entry.